AllPeriodicTables Home
AllPeriodicTables spacer
Questions?    Call Us    1-773-271-0318     9am to 2pm   Central Time   Mon.-Fri.

Questions and Answers about All Periodic Tables

Q. What is the basis of a periodic table?
The modern periodic table lists the elements in order of increasing atomic number (the number of protons in the nucleus of an atom). The periodic law: "The elements, if arranged according to their atomic weights, exhibit an evident periodicity of properties." was stated by Mendeleev in 1869, seven years after de Chancourtois was the first to use a periodic arrangement of all of the known elements, showing that similar elements appear at periodic atom weights. (details)

Q. Did Mendeleev make the first periodic table?
A. No. Alexandre Beguyer de Chancourtois' "telluric screw" was the first, as he proposed a classification of the then-known (1858) elements based on atomic weights, and plotted them on the surface of a cylinder, in a spiral. (details)

Q. Why does Mendeleev get the credit?
A. Thirteen years after the "telluric screw", and generally in parallel with Lothar Meyer’s work, Mendeleev - not initially having had the benefit of seeing de Chancourtois’ 3-D arrangement - proposed an improvement of an earlier flat table. It had eight columns, with gaps carefully arrived at related to the properties of adjacent elements. These gaps were later filled by others with previously undiscovered elements (scandium, gallium, and germanium) fitting his descriptions, and assuring his fame. (details)

Q. Is his table the familiar one?
A. No. There were shifts of his 8th column elements into another column, and a column (now called group) of gases added. The current, familiar flat form has been developed with adaptations by Bayley, then Werner, Moseley, and finally, Glenn Seaborg. (details)

Q. What did Seaborg do?
A. During his work on the atomic bomb during WWII, he and his group at Fermi Labs discovered numerous new elements. Insertion into the periodic table made the result too wide for convenience, so he proposed their removal from inside the table to a position below the remainder of the elements, under the lanthanides. (details)

Q. What other locations for elements are in question?
A. Hydrogen placement is problematic. Noted chemists and science philosophers are divided as to whether the H data should be placed in a box over Li, F, C, or no one group. The criteria vary, from atomic number triads, to electronic configurations, to ionization energy, both for H and He, and likely for others as well. (details)
Placement of exit/re-entry points of the Rare earths are also in dispute, some leaving a blank on the flat chart below Sc & Y, others putting La & Ac there, and some promoting Lu & Lr for that spot. (details)

Q. What is an "alternative periodic table" ?
A. Currently, any arrangement of chemical element symbols and information, whether 2 or 3 dimensional, not graphically represented in a flat grid such as that approved by the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC). (details)

Q. Why do we need static charts and models when the Internet is full of interactive ones?
A. One answer is its convenience and low cost due to mass production. Static charts require only the pages upon which they are printed rather than a computer and the Internet. A printed chart can not only be seen by students on the wall in virtually all science classrooms, they are in all chemistry books, and can be folded up and carried in a pocket. (details)

Q. Do we need 3-D models when flat charts are so handy?
A. Most 3-D models are intended to show an unbroken numerical sequence of the elements for new students, allowing the learner to stay on track while tracing trends, similarities, or differences for any element, clarifying the relationships of the elements for high school through college level chemistry and affiliated fields, and often provide many improvements over the flat periodic table for serious chemists and students as well.
As in the study of geography, where the globe is used to model reality followed by using maps for convenience and economy -- however distorted they may necessarily be -- the 3-D chart avoids the distortions necessary to portray element relationships on a flat surface, easing the learner into the daunting informational device that is the periodic table. They also provide more motivational, interesting, and usually hands-on, educational possibilities, while also appealing to a wider range of intellectual types. (details)

democritus periodic table patented PT groups Mendeleev symbols spiral PT dechancourtois hydrogen Mendeleev Noble neon Bohr gray Rare earths krypton Rare earths Seaborg xenon AAE Scerri DuFour other Inventors All Periodic People and Things spacer
Your place for learning about chemical element periodic tables, 2-D, 3-D, and alternatives
< previous page . . . first detail >
Democritus,  Periodic Table Basis,  Patenting,   Element Groups,  Mendeleev,  Element Symbols,  Spiral Models, de Chancourtois,  hydrogen,  Noble Gases,  neon,  Niels Bohr,  Theodore Gray,  Rare Earths, krypton,  Glenn Seaborg,  xenon,  Alexander Arrangement of Elements,  Eric Scerri,  Fernando Dufour,  Other Inventors

AlexanderDESIGN     4851 N. Washtenaw Ave., Chicago, IL 60625     773.271.0318     last update 11/23/12